Rgbstock forum

forum > General chat > Copyright crazy threat...

Copyright crazy threat...

1. mzacha25 January 2012, 16:09 GMT +01:00


2. Groningen25 January 2012, 19:25 GMT +01:00

I had to make a similar image during a course in Photoshop
am I guilty or ...?

3. Groningen25 January 2012, 19:25 GMT +01:00

I had to make a similar image during a course in Photoshop
am I guilty or ...?

4. Groningen25 January 2012, 19:25 GMT +01:00

sorry double post ;-(

5. xymonau26 January 2012, 3:14 GMT +01:00

In those particular images, the idea was certainly copied. But I'm not sure if stealing ideas is unfair. I'd have to think about that. After I did my little golden xmas tree, lots of people copied the idea and made similar images.

6. crisderaud26 January 2012, 3:33 GMT +01:00

I saw that just a moment ago here:


7. mzacha26 January 2012, 10:33 GMT +01:00

But what is that stolen idea? A red bus on a black and white photos? I made similar one (with Polish bus) around 10 years ago in my school. And I haven't seen the london version before.

So may be the bus and the Big Ben? But it is difficult not to make such picture in London ;-)

8. weirdvis26 January 2012, 10:54 GMT +01:00

Does this mean that advertising agencies using meme's from Youtube and the film industry are going to get panned too? Where will this bollocks end?

This is seriously f*cked up. The judge needs sectioningl.

9. Gramps30 January 2012, 9:07 GMT +01:00

So we just need someone who has a proven / date stamped photo that looks similar and was taken prior to the Temple Island Collection Ltd one and we can have another court case. Hmmm, I think I may have one from when I were a lad. Granted, it's a horse drawn carrage and the Houses of Parliment are still under constuction, oh and I had to paint it red, but the idea is the same !

Come on guys, get a life, nothing is original, your just money grabbing little ........

10. lennie30 January 2012, 13:47 GMT +01:00

I think most of the laws around the world are clear enough.

Ideas can not be copyrighted, that is what patents are for.

Copyright and I think patents do not apply to clothes and similair because they are considered to utilitarian:

(this is something you should watch anyway !)

There is something which is fairly new which is called a Community Design:


Which is specifically meant to prevent counterfeiting of designs (the video talks about that too).

If you take the existing image and create a derived work that would be a totally different story.

Please sign in or sign up if you want to participate in the forum discussions.